Import jQuery

Showing posts with label restoration of israel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label restoration of israel. Show all posts

Some Thoughts on Warfare


Dear Kineti readers, my friend Aaron Hecht asks you to pray and fast for Israel and her salvation in this excellent guest post. Israel is up against both significant physical and spiritual warfare. It faces a growing list of internal crises: drugs, political corruption, secularism, homelessness, emigration out of Israel due to cost of living, and more. He urges that if you support Christian organizations in Israel, that you do so only with those that preach the Gospel, as many abdicate that responsibility in order to appease Jewish religious leaders.

As anyone who reads blogs like this one will know, Israel recently came through a round of kinetic warfare with the Palestinian Islamic Jihad group in the Gaza Strip. What you might not have heard yet is that Hezbollah (a heavily armed terrorist group based in Lebanon which like PIJ in Gaza is a front for Iranian power in the region) is holding exercises this week that it has explicitly said are meant to be a dress rehearsal for an attack against Israel. Tensions between Israel and Iran, always on a simmer, appear to be escalating. Almost everyone in Israel's strategic community agrees that it is only a matter of time before a full-scale war between Israel and Iran will begin.

Kinetic wars, terrorist attacks, riots, and violence have been part of the story of the modern state of Israel since the very beginning. I've lived in this country a bit more than 20 years and I have literally lost track of the wars that have been fought here in that time. Most of these wars have been short but intense affairs like this one that just happened, with exchanges involving rockets being fired into Israel from Gaza and Israeli air strikes on terrorist targets in the Strip. There was also a medium-sized conflict between Israel and the Hezbollah terrorist group in Lebanon back in the summer of 2006. I was working for the Jerusalem Post newspaper at the time and that was a very good season for selling newspapers I can tell you that.

As someone said once, "Blood's cheap, but there's money in it."

That phrase has become highly relevant in recent months as headline after headline has appeared in Israeli news outlets announcing purchases of Israeli-built weapons systems by European countries. It would seem that the war in neighboring Ukraine has reminded Europeans that wars still happen occasionally, and they need to be ready to fight for their way of life. A similar re-awakening if this awareness and with it a renewed interest in buying weapons and ammunition in truly staggering quantities, seems to have also taken hold in Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, and even Canada.

For companies that manufacture weapons, ammunition, military equipment, electronics, and even camping gear, it's a bonanza. For taxpayers in all of these countries, it's going to mean their governments have less money and bandwidth to provide them with healthcare, education, and many other services. For many young people of an age where they're eligible to be conscripted, there might also be that possibility to contend with.

This is, of course, on top of all the other heavy news we're all dealing with.

It's a very stressful time to be alive, especially if you're like me and you have small children who have their whole lives ahead of them.

Spiritual War

In the midst of all this, the last month saw something happen that gave me a great deal of comfort.

I am referring by the initiative coming from the International House of Prayer (IHOP) in Kansas City to pray for Israel and the salvation of the Jewish people in the 21 days leading up to Shavuot (Pentecost.) Millions of Christians all over the world joined this initiative, including several congregations here in Israel, and the results are already beginning to emerge.

Brothers and sisters, with all due respect to the active kinetic wars in Ukraine and Israel, and the rumors of imminent wars between Israel and Iran, China and Taiwan, North and South Korea, and many other places, this prayer initiative was the really big story this past month.

Prayer and fasting are the weapons of spiritual warfare that every follower of Jesus of Nazareth has at their disposal, and it is with these weapons that we fight the spiritual war of which these physical kinetic battles are merely a shadow.

I beg to draw your attention to the following passages of Scripture.

II Corinthians 10:3-5 says,

For though we walk in the flesh, we do not wage battle according to the flesh, for the weapons of our warfare are not of the flesh, but divinely powerful for the destruction of fortresses. We are destroying arguments and all arrogance raised against the knowledge of God, and we are taking every thought captive to the obedience of Christ.

Ephesians 6:12 says,

For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the powers, against the world forces of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places.

Revelation 12:11 says, 

And they overcame him because of the blood of the Lamb and because of the word of their testimony, and they did not love their life even when faced with death.

Brothers and sisters, the REAL wars being waged in this season of history we're passing through aren't being fought with tanks, missiles, drones, and machine guns. The battlefields aren't in faraway places in Eastern Europe, the Pacific Rim, or even the Gaza envelope.

There is a battle being fought for the hearts and minds of my children and yours. There are battles being fought over my marriage and yours. There are spiritual forces working to tear apart families, congregations, denominations, and entire civilizations. The dark forces of Hell know their time is short, and they're not holding anything back. They're not saving anything for later, because they know there won't be a later for them. They're doing everything they can, while they still can, to take as many human beings as they can with them into an eternity in Hell, separated from God.

Orthodox Jewish protesters demonstrating against Christians during Shavuot (Pentecost) last week. Protesters shouted, "Missionaries go home!" outside the Davidson Center, where Christian groups had gathered for Pentecost 2023: A Global Day of Prayer for Jerusalem.


Why would they do that? They would do that because it's all they've got left. It's the only thing they can do. They hate human beings so much that even though they know they've got no future, they can at least indulge their hatred of human beings and destroy the future for as many of us as they can.

You and I can't punch Satan in the face. We can't pick up a hammer and hit him with it. We can't shoot him with a gun or run over him with a truck.

But we can push back against his plans and purposes for our lives, the lives of our children, and the lives of our congregations and communities, and nations. We can push back with our prayers and our fasting, and that's what this recent initiative led by IHOP was meant to do. I would encourage everyone who was part of that initiative to keep praying and if it's medically safe for you to do so, try to fast at least once a week.

Most congregations and fellowships designate at least one evening a week for prayer. Find out if your congregation has such a prayer evening and make it a priority to join it, and that would be a good day for you to fast. If there isn't one, ask your pastor to let you start one.

If Israel and the Jewish People aren't on your list of things to pray about yet, please start praying for us.

I'd like to suggest a few issues regarding Israel and the Jewish People that you can pray into.

Almost everyone knows that Israel is surrounded by hostile, heavily armed neighbors with which we've fought several wars in the past. Everyone knows about the ever-present threat of terrorist attacks.

What you might be less aware of is the rise in recent years in violent crime in this country. Most of this crime happens within the Arab community, but there's plenty of violence that Jews are also victims of. There's also an appalling amount of domestic violence, sexual abuse of children (increasingly this abuse is being committed by other children, often from within the victim's own family), and many other heartbreaking problems. Drug abuse, while still at levels far below most other Western countries, is also on the rise and Israel is actually grappling with a rate of opioid abuse that is above the rates in many other Western countries.

In short, all the problems you're used to hearing about where you're from are here too, and in some respects, they're even worse.

Another problem Israelis are dealing with is a spiraling cost of living. Everything from groceries to real estate to gasoline and everything in between is more expensive here than it should be. The reasons are complex and solutions have eluded one governing coalition after another for decades. But the effects are all-too-easy to discern, including a small but growing exodus of people who have a passport that allows them to live in other countries. In the 20 years I've lived here I've gone to dozens of parties to say goodbye to someone who was leaving Israel to go live in America, Canada, Western Europe, or even as far away as South Africa or Australia. The expense of living here was a factor in nearly every single one of those decisions.

Just a few days ago I got a message from a woman I studied with in Ulpan when I was a new immigrant back in the day, saying that she was getting ready to pack up her daughter and move back to France. It was utterly shocking to me since this woman is one of the most strongly Zionist people I've ever known, but she told me very candidly that she just can't afford to live here anymore.

So brothers and sisters, by all means, pray for Israel to be strengthened and protected against the military threats from Iran, the terrorist groups in and around Israel, and all the non-kinetic but still very serious rhetorical threats Israel faces at the UN, on university campuses all over the world, etc.

But spare some time to pray into some of the more pedestrian issues that affect Israel, like crime, drug abuse, domestic violence, and just the simple cost of living.

Toward Israel's salvation

Last but certainly not least, I would ask you to pray for the Gospel to be proclaimed and received in this country, and for the already existing Body of Christ to be strengthened and expanded. This is an issue that I have long had strong feelings about but in the last year or so I've become actually very angry at the way it's being neglected and even opposed by many self-described Christian Zionists.

There are, sadly, many Israel-supporting Christians who are on a spectrum of Dual Covenant thinking that causes them to treat the Gospel and Israel's household of faith with indifference and in some cases, even outright opposition and hostility.

This has got to stop.

Dual Covenant Theology is a ludicrously absurd lie from the Pit of Hell and it is baffling to me that it even exists, much less that it has become so widespread. Even a very casual reading of the New Testament scriptures will allow anyone who is sincerely interested in the truth to refute this idea, but there are some passages in particular that utterly demolish it. 

My personal favorite is Romans 11:15, where the Apostle Paul, speaking of the Jewish people, said,

For if their rejection (of the Gospel) proves to be the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead? 

I don't know about you, gentle reader, but I look around and see a world that's dying. If there's going to be any life in this dying world, the Scripture tells us that Jewish people accepting their Messiah is what will bring it. If you're not praying for that, and if possible WORKING for it, then you're part of the problem. If you're working AGAINST this goal, as some who call themselves "Christian Zionists" sadly are (mostly because of Dual Covenant Theology, which is the great curse of Christian Zionism) then you're REALLY part of the problem.

As I said before, Satan and his demons aren't holding anything back. They're not saving anything for later. They know this is the end game. You and I have to internalize that as well. We need to get in this fight and stay in until it's finished.

We need to be fasting regularly and praying daily for our own families, our own congregations, our own governments (including people we might not have voted for), and our own pastoral leadership. We also need to be praying for Israel and the Jewish People, and if possible we also need to be WORKING for Israel and the Jewish People, and that most definitely includes their salvation.

One last thing.

Brothers and sisters, it is my sad duty to inform you that there is a LOT of money, time, effort, energy, and resources being sent to "do the work of the Kingdom" in Israel but it's not being utilized in a way that'll bring any fruit for the Kingdom. That doesn't mean the work of the Kingdom won't get done, or even that it'll be slowed down. But it DOES mean that a lot of money, time, effort, energy, and resources are being wasted, and that's obviously not what we want.

So if you're giving money, time, prayer, or any other kind of support to any Christian organization that is working in Israel, I BEG OF YOU(!!!) to find out what that organization is doing to share the Gospel with the Jewish People and support the Body of Christ in this country.

Call the leadership of these organizations up and ask them direct questions. If they don't give you direct answers, they're probably trying to hide something from you and it's probably not for a good reason.

If they DO give you answers, do some cross-checking. Ask around and find out if they're being completely honest and transparent. If you find out they're not, then ask them why they're being less than completely honest with you. Once again, if they don't, can't, or won't give you a direct answer, you'll know something's wrong.

Before you do this though, cover yourself in prayer and make a VERY serious effort to read the Biblical passages related to the Jewish People and their need for the Gospel. Then do some reading to find out what "Dual Covenant Theology" is all about and where it comes from and what the buzzwords are, and otherwise how you'll know it when you see it. 

If you do that, and then you start investigating the Christian Zionist organizations that are operating in Israel, it probably won't take you very long to see exactly what I'm talking about in this blog.

So brothers and sisters, in conclusion, I encourage you to get more involved in fighting the spiritual war. The weapons of our warfare are prayer, fasting, our testimony, and our faith. These weapons are sharpened by regular Bible study, prayer, and fellowship with other Believers.

Now stop reading this blog and go do all that stuff!

The gospel is not “Believe in Jesus so that you’ll go to heaven”

Quick: what is “the gospel”?  

In my corner of the religious world, I’ve often heard the gospel described as believing in Jesus so that you’ll go to heaven when you die.

That may be an outcome of the gospel – trusting in God's Messiah produces resurrection and eternal life – but it is not the gospel itself.

Look at the first 4 books of the New Testament – the gospels – you’ll find a different message:

John: “Repent! The kingdom of God is near.”
-Matthew 3

Yeshua: “Repent, for the kingdom of God is near.”
-Matthew 4

Peter: “Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Yeshua the Messiah for the forgiveness of your sin.”
-Acts 2

See a common theme? The Messiah, the Messiah’s Elijah, and the Messiah’s chief disciple share this message.

The gospel is actually a very old message, with a new urgency. In a nutshell, the gospel is: "Turn from your sins to God." This is the same message of the prophets in the Hebrew Bible. 

And the new urgency is: "Because the Kingdom of God is near."

The Kingdom of God: the Messianic Era

imageThe arrival of the long-awaited Messiah was a divine down-payment on the promises of the good things to come, an assurance that God's Big Plan, including the epic this-changes-everything Kingdom of God, was near. Therefore, we must turn from sin now and turn back to God.

The Kingdom of God is the final empire on earth in which all nations are in submission to God, with God’s Messiah reigning over all nations. This Kingdom of God, this Messianic Era, is drawing near, and the arrival of King Messiah himself is evidence of its nearness.

In the Messianic Era, atheism and agnosticism will cease to exist given the empirical evidence of God. World religions will crumble with revelation that there is only one God. The rebellious nature of humanity will be quelled as the world acknowledges God and recognizes the goodness in following God’s ways. Adultery, murder, theft, and other crimes decrease and finally cease, as the adversary is put away, no longer permitted to deceive humanity, producing humans that see clearly the folly and destruction of sin.

“In the Messianic Era, we will all ☪☮e✡i✝ under one King.”

In the Messianic Era, we will all ☪☮e✡i✝, but under one King: all people, races, nations, philosophies, science, religions, and ideologies will submit to the King of all Kings. The whole populace of earth will acknowledge God and worship him.

Humanity united under one king will produce real actual genuine world peace, instituted by the Prince of Peace, the great Jewish King reigning from Jerusalem, Yeshua the Messiah.

This is the Kingdom of God, this is the Messianic Era.

Knowing the Messianic Era is near means there’s no time to waste: turn back to God now. That’s the gospel. That’s the core message of Yeshua, John, the disciples, and Paul. It’s the old message of the prophets, but with a new urgency knowing that God’s making good on his promises, and with Messiah’s arrival, it’s all starting to happen now.

This is a snippet from my recent teaching at my local congregation:

Elementary Principles of Messianic Faith, Part III

The Church and the Jews

What a striking work! Inspiring! And also quite different from Jewish Messianic literature today.

Two things struck me when reading these papers. First, the emphasis on Christianity. And second, their certainty of the coming kingdom of God.

Here’s a snippet:

“From my youth up I have been occupied with religious problems and eventually I came to the conviction that Jesus of Nazareth is the Messiah of Israel and the Redeemer of the world.

This conviction did not lead me away from my Jewish people. On the contrary, it unfolded for me the unique significance of Israel in the Divine purpose.

I have walked on many paths, of life, of faith, of politics, and of the spirit. They were needed in order to gather experience. Much vanished as unessential, much appeared as of importance, but one thing alone took entire possession of me: Jewish Christianity.

If the Divine revelation to Israel is an objective reality and if Jesus is the promised Messiah, then the present day Jewish-Christian movement is of great historical significance and a sign of the times.

This I believe to be the case.

I want to tell my brethren that we Jewish Christians have not forsaken or betrayed our people, but remain true to it in all its dangers and necessities. We love our people and will never grow weary of striving to obtain its confidence.

Consistent Jewish Christians are at present without a home in the world, but theirs is the future.

In this faith we speak and act. To have this faith means beholding the spiritual, seeking the eternal in time, and living and working in the present for the future. Our gaze is not fixed upon our own day only, but upon the centuries. We look to the end.

The apostles of the New Testament as well as the prophets of the Old Testament were convinced that the “remnant” of Israel will be saved.

When this will take place we do not know, but we do know that God knows it, and so we can leave the when and the how to Him. It is for us to sow; others, who will come after, will reap. We have neither begun the work, nor shall we finish it. At all times, and in all lands, there have been Jewish Christians, like the “Nicodemus Jews,” the secret believers in Palestine to-day. They did not appear publicly, none knew of them, for the time was not yet ripe.

But to-day the time is fulfilled, and the flag with the Cross in the Star of David is flying.

Joseph Rabinowitz and his circle fulfilled the task in their day; we fulfill it in ours, and they who come after us will fulfill it in the future, until the time shall come which shall call Israel to its highest task and bring the hour of final fulfillment…

But all of us are built upon that foundation of all time and of all eternity: Jesus the Christ. Here is the root of our strength, here is the secret of that power which has worked through the centuries and which will conquer in the future.

Whether some smile, and others shake their heads, and the rest say it is impossible, we go on our way undeterred to the End. For we know that the Christ always does the impossible and He is a “tireless Hunter”. We see the light in the darkness and the day in the night, the rainbow of peace above the storms of time, the Sign in the Heavens as the promise of Victory.”

Jews that believe in Yeshua in modern times, going by the name Messianic Jews, very often refrain from associating themselves with Christianity. Many of us like to view ourselves apart from pagan and defiled Christianity. For better or worse, this was not so with some of the early pioneers of modern Messianic Judaism who, by any measure, were Jewish Christians who saw themselves as part of the fulfillment of the restoration of Israel, fully embodied within Christianity.

As I read these old reprinted materials from Jewish Christians in the 1930s, ‘40s, and ‘50s, I started to realize just how lacking we are today, to understate the matter. Our faith life is junk compared to these men and women. It’s our turn, it’s our time to fulfill that time of Israel restoration! And what have we done? Most of us have been found off to the side, bickering and dividing ourselves until we’re just a bunch of small, easily conquerable Republic of Daves, Kingdom of Toms. What a shame we have wasted so much of our time with infighting.

Here they were, before the recreation of the state of Israel, at a time when most believed God was done with the Jews, with persecution coming from both Judaism and Christianity; here they remained firm in their identity, certain of God’s plan and coming kingdom, rejoicing in what’s to come. Not focused on various doctrinal errors or pagan influences, but rejoicing in what God’s doing.

Maybe I’m being too Grandpa Tevye, maybe I’m thinking the grass is always greener. But a casual reading of these papers reveals a hope and certainty I don’t have. I’m envious.

Plans to prosper Israel the Church.

My son attends a Christian school, whose walls are adorned with Scriptures like this one:

“For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the LORD, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.”

-Jeremiah 29

jeremiah29,11,13_1024

It’s a nice, uplifting piece of Scripture.

My mother-in-law, who occasionally reads this blog (hi Sue) has a picture of bird houses, flower pots, and other crafts. Underlining the picture is a verse from the Torah,

For the LORD your God will bless you in all the work of your hands, and your joy will be complete.

-Deuteronomy 16

They are nice, uplifting verses. We find comfort in them.

While they’re uplifting, it’s important to understand that they were not intended to be used this way; they weren’t intended to be motivational tidbits to help gentiles get through the day. Let me show you what I mean and why that’s important.

Here is Jeremiah 29 in context:

This is what the LORD says: "When seventy years are completed for Babylon, I will come to you and fulfill my gracious promise to bring you back to this place. For I know the plans I have for you," declares the LORD, "plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future. Then you will call upon me and come and pray to me, and I will listen to you. You will seek me and find me when you seek me with all your heart. I will be found by you," declares the LORD, "and will bring you back from captivity. I will gather you from all the nations and places where I have banished you," declares the LORD, "and will bring you back to the place from which I carried you into exile."

-Jeremiah 29

This prophecy is specifically to the House of Judah (that is, the southern Israelite nation comprised primary of the tribes of Judah and Benjamin). The nation of Judah was taken captive to Babylon for 70 years, and here Jeremiah is prophesying to those exiled Israelites that God will bring them out of captivity and prosper them.

This was not a promise to all young Christian school children that God would prosper them.

Looking at the other example, here is Deuteronomy 16 in context:

Celebrate the Feast of Tabernacles for seven days after you have gathered the produce of your threshing floor and your winepress. Be joyful at your Feast—you, your sons and daughters, your menservants and maidservants, and the Levites, the aliens, the fatherless and the widows who live in your towns. For seven days celebrate the Feast to the LORD your God at the place the LORD will choose. For the LORD your God will bless you in all your harvest and in all the work of your hands, and your joy will be complete.

-Deuteronomy 16

Here we have a succinct commandment for Israel to keep Succot, God’s Feast of Tabernacles. If Israel does this, they’ll be blessed, God’s decree.

Some Christians have retrofitted this verse to mean, “Anything I work on, God will prosper, and I’ll be joyful as a result.” A nice sentiment, but ultimately an untrue statement. I mean, God doesn’t prosper everything you work on. Let’s be real here, guys, God doesn’t prosper the garden out in our front yard just because our precious hands worked on it.

Why it matters

Messianic Rabbi Derek Leman discusses the shocking Israel-centric nature of the Scriptures, saying,

Passages like [Jeremiah] gave rise to a problem of interpretation. When Jews brought the Bible to non-Jews confusion started very early. When a non-Jew reads his or her Bible it is with certainty that the everlasting love of God is for him or her too. So how do we interpret and teach these passages?

The common approach is to ignore the original intent. The love letter to Israel is appropriated by non-Israel. A pastor preaches Jeremiah 31:3 as God’s love for all. A youth pastor puts a poster of Jeremiah 29:11 on the wall. It’s a bit like stealing a line from someone else’s love letter and addressing it to yourself or to someone else.

So we’re stealing God’s love letters to Israel and making it address us Christians instead. Big deal?

Yes, it is. While the intent may be honorable – uplifting Christians in their walk with God – we must see this as a minute manifestation of replacement theology. (An anti-Jewish theology that states the Church and Christians have replaced or superseded Israel and the Jews as God’s people.) This form of Scriptural interpretation is doing exactly that: taking God’s promises and blessings, and replacing the intended recipient, Israel, with a new recipient, the Church and Christians.

What about the New Testament?

Were Messiah’s words only for Israel? This is a tough question, because he often spoke in generalities and parables that might be applied to anyone. For example, it would seem the Beatitudes in Matthew 5 are universal – blessed are the peacemakers, the meek, the merciful, those who are hungry for righteousness. On the other hand, if the beatitudes are universal, so is the Messiah’s commandment in 5:17 regarding keeping the Torah, meaning the Torah is applicable to all Christians.

It is my opinion that Messiah’s words were directed to Israel, with full knowledge that gentiles would be grafted-in.

And what about Paul, whose letters were almost entirely to gentiles. Paul talks about the “assembly”, often translated “church”. So surely he means Christians, right?

The answer is: yes, but not in the way we’d like to think.

Paul talks about believers in Messiah being part of Israel.

Remember that formerly you who are Gentiles by birth and called "uncircumcised" by those who call themselves "the circumcision" — remember that at that time you were separate from Messiah, excluded from citizenship in Israel and foreigners to the covenants of the promise, without hope and without God in the world. But now in Messiah Yeshua you who once were far away have been brought near through the blood of Messiah.

-Paul, in his letter to the assembly at Ephesus

Stop and let that sink in for a moment. Part of Israel. A citizen of Israel, God’s people. You haven’t replaced Israel; Abraham’s physical descendants remain God’s vehicle for blessing the world. But now, with your faith in the God of Israel and its Messiah, you’re now joined to Israel. First-class citizen of Israel. First-class Israelite, even though you’re a gentile.

To underline this fact, Paul tells gentile Corinthians that the great Hebrew ancestors of old -- Moses, Abraham, Jacob -- are "our fathers", that is, fathers of both Jews and gentiles in Messiah.

Brothers, I do not want you to be ignorant of the fact that our forefathers were all under the cloud and that they all passed through the sea. They were all baptized into Moses in the cloud and in the sea. They all ate the same spiritual food and drank the same spiritual drink; for they drank from the spiritual rock that accompanied them, and that rock was Messiah.

-Paul, in his letter to the assembly in Corinth

Gentiles are joined to the commonwealth of Israel and share Israel’s heritage, as Paul says. Because of this, I believe gentiles can read these Israel-centric Scriptures to apply them to themselves, even as non-Jews who believe in Messiah.

However, there are conditions for these blessings so many wish to apply to themselves.

Too often, Christians read Scriptural blessings to Israel and apply it to themselves without considering the terms of the blessing.

In Deuteronomy 16, the condition was keeping God’s feasts.

In Jeremiah 29, the condition is throwing off the old ways and seeking the Lord.

In Psalm 1, the condition is delighting in the Torah.

With so many of these blessings contingent on keeping God’s commandments, it should not come as a surprise that the Church of our time is riddled with spiritual famine and abuse.

Gentiles should become Jews?

No, but we do desire Christians to live like they’re serving the God of Israel, rather than merely abiding within the boundaries of a religion that has traditionally distanced itself from, and even persecuted, Israel.

Gentiles who have found the Messiah of Israel have a place as citizens in the commonwealth of Israel. You can relate to all those things that happened to Israel, because you’re now joined to Israel, a citizen of God’s people Israel. Your forefathers crossed the Red Sea. Your ancestors were delivered out of Egypt. Your family has received the Torah from God’s finger. The God of Israel graciously pulled you from the downward-spiraling gentile world and gave you a shot at life, by grafting you into Israel and his ways – Torah – that lead to life.

Because Messiah has grafted you into the commonwealth of Israel, it’s no longer “God of their fathers”. Instead, it’s “My God, the God of my fathers, the God of Israel who brought us out of the land of Egypt and bondage.”

My brother on Israel National News

As Arutz Sheva’s reporters were interviewing folks on the streets regarding Israel's upcoming election, they met up with my younger brother and asked what he had to say:



You can see him at about 15:00 into the video, where he tells the reporter,

“The most important issue is that this is HaShem’s land and this is the land not to be divided and given to our enemies.”

Conclusions on Former Gentiles

You, a former gentile who believes in Messiah, are no longer foreign to the covenants God made with Israel. You used to be alienated from Israel, now you’re not. No longer an alien/foreigner, but a first-class member of God’s people.

The other week, we critically dissected the first part of Ephesians 2, where Paul makes this claim of gentiles-as-first class citizens, in God’s kingdom, no longer foreigners to Israel and the covenants God made with his people; now part of the commonwealth of Israel.

Enjoy your first class seat!

114602488820060426 Air Canada Solar Seat

Since then, we’ve had a lot of vehement debate.

The initial post generated a 15 responses as folks interpreted Paul’s letter in light of their own theologies.

A week later as we discussed this in more detail, wondering just exactly what Paul meant by this mutation:

Initial state:

  • Apart from God
  • Alienated from Israel
  • Strangers to the covenants God made with Israel

New state:

  • Brought near to God through Messiah
  • Joined to the commonwealth of Israel
  • Partakers of God’s covenants with Israel

Beware the mutant gentiles!  

That means gentiles have been brought near to God through Messiah, are no longer aliens to Israel, and are no longer strangers to the covenants God made with Israel.

That's some pretty deep theology there.

We finally looked at the last half of Ephesians 2. Sweet goodness, did you guys have a lot to say on this! As of this writing, we’ve have 49 comments of debate discussing this last bit where Paul tells us a mystery: this metamorphosis has come because Messiah broke down the wall dividing Jew and gentile. By abolishing the Torah on the cross.

Yeah, about that last part. As much as some Christians want that to be true, it just doesn’t pan out, as we’ll shortly see.

Let’s get out our scalpel and finish this sucker! Here is the last bit of Ephesians 2: it’s nice and short, but contains some real doozies!

He is our peace, who made both one.

He broke down the middle wall, the enmity in his flesh, the law of the commands in ordinances having done away, that the two he might create in himself into one new man, making peace, to reconcile both in one body to God through the cross, having slain the enmity in it.

He came and proclaimed good news – peace to you – both far off and near, because through him we have the access – we both – in one Spirit unto the Father.

Then, therefore, you are no longer strangers and foreigners, but fellow-citizens of the house of God, being built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Yeshua Messiah himself being chief corner-[stone], in whom all the building fitly framed together increases to an holy sanctuary in the Lord, in whom also you are built together, for a home of God in the Spirit.

-Paul, in his letter to Ephesus

Whew. Let’s dissect this and see what comes out.

He is our peace, who made both one.

Who’s he talking about when he says “both”? Because we’ve studied this thing in context, we know he’s talking about Israel and the gentiles.

Ok, so to paraphrase, here’s conclusion #1: “Messiah is our peace who made Israel and the gentiles as one.”

Paul explains this a bit:

He broke down the middle wall, the enmity in his flesh, the law of the commands in ordinances having done away, that the two he might create in himself into one new man, making peace, to reconcile both in one body to God through the cross, having slain the enmity in it.

He broke down the wall that divided us. Ok, good good good. Don’t know what the enmity in his flesh is. Skipping… He did away with the enmity, which is the Torah, slaying it on the cross. Good good…erhm, wait, WHAT?! 

Many Christians interpret this verse in this way: “Jesus Christ slew the Torah on the cross.”

Slew. To slay. That means, “destroy with violence”.

JesusRifle (3) = Broken Law

Is that how you interpret this, dear blog reader?

Here Paul just finished saying how gentiles are no longer foreigners to Israel and the covenants (including the Mosaic covenant!). But then Paul supposedly says, “Oh, and Messiah destroyed the covenants by slaying them on the cross.”

Folks, it ain’t addin’ up! </southern drawl>

Joking aside, there’s a deeply-rooted flaw with such an interpretation. If Paul is saying what some wish him to be saying, then Paul is contrary to Messiah, contrary to the prophets, contrary to the Psalms, contrary to pretty much all of Scripture. If Paul is saying, “Jesus violently destroyed and abolished the Torah on the cross”, then Paul’s writings would have the need to be violently ripped from the New Testament!

Fortunately, Paul is not saying that.

Fortunately, Paul is in alignment with Messiah.

And we don’t have to perform any airy spiritual acrobatics to interpret in such a way that Messiand and Paul are not at odds with each other.

After discussing this verse with you fine blog readers and hearing your own interpretations, my own interpretation comes to this, conclusion #2:

As Israel was kept separate from the nations through Torah, hostility abounded. Messiah destroyed the hostility-wall.

Simple.

And no Scriptural acrobatics required.

acrobatics

So Messiah destroyed the hostility between Jew and gentile, Israel and the nations. Ok, how exactly is that accomplished? Since Torah is still here (as Messiah said, “until heaven and earth pass away”), how is it that there’s no hostility between Jew and gentile?

Well, truth be told, there is still hostility. I sense it even on this blog, in the comments. I sense it in the religion of Messianic Judaism.

But if we are walking perfectly with Messiah, that hostility would not exist. And this is Paul’s next point:

He came and proclaimed good news – peace to you – both far off and near, because through him we have the access – we both – in one Spirit unto the Father.

This hostility is broken down because we both have equal access to God through Messiah. If I could paraphrase, I’d say, “Messiah brought good news to both Israel and the gentiles: through Him, both have access to God.”

Makes sense.

And Paul ties it all together – why was he talking about “former gentiles” before? How does this fit?

Therefore, you are no longer strangers and foreigners, but fellow-citizens of the house of God, being built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Yeshua Messiah himself being chief corner-[stone], in whom all the building framed together increases to an holy sanctuary in the Lord, in whom also you are built together, for a home of God in the Spirit.

Gentiles are no longer strangers to the things of God: Israel or the covenants with Israel. Instead, you’re fellow-citizens with Israel. You’re built on Messiah, the prophets, the apostles. You’re the Temple. 

Conclusion 

To summarize and paraphrase, this is what Ephesians 2 is all about:

You gentiles used to follow the ways of the world, sinning without remorse. Rebels against God. You were dead. You were separate from Israel. A complete foreigner to all of the covenants God made with His people Israel --no Torah, no God, no life!

But God loved all humanity; he saved us by giving Messiah. He did it to show how great He is. It's all Him, we sure didn't warrant it!

Now even gentiles can be set right with God.

In doing this, Messiah became that shalom that makes Jew and gentile as one.

Because of the Torah, there was hostility between Israel and the gentiles. But He destroyed this hostility by bringing peace to both Jew and gentile, giving both of us access to God.

Because of that, you gentiles are fellow citizens with Israel in God’s house, you each have become a Temple to house God’s Spirit, a Temple built on the prophets and the apostles, with Messiah himself as the bedrock.

-My summarized, simplified interpretation of Ephesians 2

After weeks of Scriptural study and having heard the opinions and interpretations of you fine blog readers, this is the conclusion I’ve drawn.

One thing I was hoping this study would do is give us a better idea of how Torah applies to gentiles, and whether gentiles become Jews.

It’s shed a little light, I think:

  • Gentiles do not magically change lineage to become Jews. Gentiles are still non-Jews, the nations.
  • Gentiles are no longer foreigners to the any of God’s covenants, including the Torah.
  • Gentiles are fellow citizens of the commonwealth of Israel

Does that mean Torah applies to gentiles?

If you are not a foreigner, but a fellow citizen of the commonwealth of Israel, Torah applies to even the gentiles who were once far off but now are near.

It makes sense, doesn’t it? If God wants even the previously-unclean gentiles to be clean, wouldn’t He apply the same standard of cleanliness to both Jew and gentile?

He told Israel how to be holy in a day-to-day life using very practical and concise commandments about what’s right and what’s wrong. Christian blog reader, you may be surprised to know these day-to-day instructions exist in the first half of your Bible.

There exists but one standard of right and wrong for God’s people, whether native born Israelites or you former gentiles who are fellow citizens, joined to the commonwealth of Israel, no longer foreigners to God’s covenants with Israel. That standard is Torah, embodied by Messiah who showed us how to live. Messiah made Jew and gentile as equals before God not by destroying the Torah, but by giving both Jews and gentiles access to God through himself.

Former gentiles, because Messiah abolished the Law?


So last week we looked at a curious Pauline quote from the Christian Scriptures that suggests something profound:

Gentiles who believe in Messiah have undergone a metamorphosis. They’re no longer far off from God, they are no longer aliens to Israel, no longer foreigners to the covenants God made with Israel.

You fine blog readers sure had your opinions on these bits!

Reader Societvs was convinced Paul is not saying gentiles become Jews,

I do not believe we become Jewish at all – this is not what happens in real life. I do not become a Christian and all of a sudden ‘poof’ I am Jewish too.

Longtime reader Efrayim brings up the point about our fuzzy understanding of Jew and gentile, and how they fit into God’s people Israel,

Before you can have any meaningful discourse about this subject you must first define your terms.

What exactly is a "gentile"?

What exactly is a "Jew"?

And most important of all, Who is Israel?

Another reader, Jeff, also comments on the blurry understanding of Jew and gentile,

I often have fun with this statement of Paul. I ask "What is the opposite of a Gentile?" The answer is usually "Jew". Then I show them this quote of Paul where we are to be former Gentiles. Then I watch their head spin. :)

Longtime reader and friend Lou Vasquez comments on the confusion surrounding terms like Jew and gentile,

Most of the confusion comes from the English translations and doctrine over the past 2000 years. It’s like the word “law” in scripture. Every time it is said it does not necessarily mean Torah. Sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn’t.

So too with the word Gentiles. Sometimes it means “Physical bloodline” other times it means “Nations that don’t know God”.

Look at the scripture,

Gal 3:28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 

Does this mean that when we are “in Christ”, woman are no longer female? Of course not.

So I believe that what is being said by Paul is God is about reconciling, and they have now (Gentiles) come into the household of God.

Messianic Jew Gene Shlomovich has a different take on things,

I do not interpret that passage in the way you did, nor I believe that Paul meant for it to be interpreted this way at all - to say that Gentiles are no longer such.

All it says, the Gentiles in the flesh were once (formerly) alienated from the covenants of Israel. The formerly part speaks about their lost CONDITION, not their past or current ethnic identity. It doesn't say that they are no longer Gentiles.

And not to be forgotten, Todd, our resident Catholic, adds his 2¢,

The early church fathers often divided people into 3 categories: Jews, Christians, and Gentiles. In Greek the third word is literally translated "nations" I believe. And could also be translated as heathen or pagan. But as you probably know, the oldest Jewish term of the non-Jewish people is probably "the nations". Basically, from their Jewish-Christian teachers the gentile Christians learned that they had become something else...in that sense they were "former gentiles". And of course in a mysterious sense they were joined to Israel and in another sense the "New Israel".

Wow! So we have a lot of varying opinions. My own opinion of this Scripture is something I’m working out as I continue to study this and align it with the rest of Scripture.

Before we interpret the first part, however, we must understand the whole of what Paul’s saying. Here is the rest of Ephesians 2, which contains some big theological swords!

For he himself is our peace, who has made the two one and has destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall of hostility, by abolishing in his flesh the law with its commandments and regulations. His purpose was to create in himself one new man out of the two, thus making peace, and in this one body to reconcile both of them to God through the cross, by which he put to death their hostility. He came and preached peace to you who were far away and peace to those who were near. For through him we both have access to the Father by one Spirit.

Consequently, you are no longer foreigners and aliens, but fellow citizens with God's people and members of God's household, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the chief cornerstone. In him the whole building is joined together and rises to become a holy temple in the Lord. And in him you too are being built together to become a dwelling in which God lives by his Spirit.

-Paul, in his letter to Ephesus

Uh oh.

Houston, we have a problem.

I guess I should stop celebrating the Father’s feasts, because it looks like Paul is saying Messiah has abolished the Torah, which includes the Feasts I’ve been so gung-ho about. And somebody better tell all those Jews who are keeping the Torah because God said it would be an "everlasting, eternal convenant" with Israel - I guess God just meant "eternal, until Jesus comes".

Didn’t Paul get the memo where Messiah said he wouldn’t abolish the Torah? Are Paul and Messiah in conflict?

Stay tuned. Later on we’ll get out our scalpel and dissect this sucker.

In the meantime, what do you fine blog readers think Paul is saying here? Has Messiah abolished the Torah so that Jews and gentiles can together become one?

Messianic Jews on Israeli News

Israel's Channel 2 featured a news segment on the Messianic Jews in Yad HaShmona, Israel:



I have some family going to Yad HaShmona during the Feast of Tabernacles this week - it's cool to see some of the stuff God's doing in that place, indeed, in the whole land of Israel.

Aviad Cohen - Revelation 22

I've written before about Aviad Cohen. He's a Jewish music artist, a hip-hop/techno artist formerly known as 50 Shekel. 3 years ago, Aviad came to the belief that Yeshua is the Messiah of Israel.

Since then, Aviad's taken a lot of flak from the Jewish community for this.

This past week, he's released his 2nd album as a believer in Yeshua, Fire Starter. Aviad's music is a kind of hip-hop/techno beat, not usually my cup of tea, but Aviad's heart really comes through in his songs.

One of the things I love from his albums is his reading of Scripture set to music. Here's a little sample: Aviad reading Revelation 22, the last chapter of the Scripture, where Messiah shows John a part of God's plan for the future.










I, Yeshua, have sent my messenger to witness to you these matters in the assemblies.

I am the root and offspring of David,
The bright morning star.

The spirit and bride say, "Come!"
He who hears say, "Come!"
He who thirsts say, "Come!"
And he who desires it, take the water of life without paying.

I witness to everyone hearing the words prophecy of this book:
If anyone adds to them, Elohim shall add to him the plagues written in this book.
If anyone takes away from this prophecy, Elohim will take him out of the book of Life
And out of the set-apart city which are written in this book.

He that bears witness to these matters says, "I am coming quickly!"

Amen! Come master Yeshua!

The favor of our master Yeshua the Messiah be with the set-apart ones, amen.

Gentiles and the Sabbath

Here is what the Master says:
"Keep justice, do what's right; my saving power is near, my righteousness will soon be revealed."


There is joy and happiness -- blessing! -- for the person who does this, the one who takes hold of it, who keeps Shabbat and does not profane it, and keeps himself from evil.

A gentile joining Adonai should not say,
"Adonai will keep me separate from Israel."
Neither should the lowly eunuch say,
"I am only a dried-up tree."


Because here is what the Master says:
"I will give power to even the powerless eunuchs who keep my Shabbat, who choose what pleases me and hold fast to my covenant. In my house, they will be given an everlasting name, never to be removed."


And the gentiles who join themselves to Adonai to serve him, to love the name Yah, every one of them who keeps Shabbat and doesn't profane it, and hold fast to my covenant, I will bring them into my house on my holy mountain and make them happy and joyful; all they offer and sacrifice will be acceptable to me.

My house will be called a house of prayer for all nations and all peoples.

Adonai Elohim, the Master who gathers Israel's exiles, decrees it:
"I will gather others to them besides the ones already gathered."


-Isaiah 56

(Preach it, Isaiah! :-))

Atonement from the Jewish Perspective

From Dr. Michael Kagan, a religious Jew,










Kagan talks about how Christianity has "went its separate way" from the Hebrew faith, but the real red meat of what he's saying is this: Christianity's idea of atonement for sin isn't really foreign to Judaism. In fact, it sprouted out of Judaism.

Take these provoking bits Kagan had to say on Jesus' arrival on the Judaic scene 2000 years ago:

This whole "technology" of atonement worked: it was shown on Yom Kippur, when a red string that was put around the goat would turn to white, and the high priest would come out of the Holy of Holies with his face shining, and everyone would be singing. And if things went wrong, we'd know: if atonement could not be made, chances are the Cohen HaGadol, the high priest, would die in the Holy of Holies. They'd have to pull him out by a string. And send somebody back, and he would give sacrifices for atonement for himself, his family, for Israel, and ultimately the whole world.

Things began to fall to pieces about 2000 years ago. The "technology" began to become out of date. There was a lot of corruption in the cohenot, in the priesthood. It is said it was lucky for a priest to go for even a season without dying, or getting kicked out of the job. There were murders, ...it was terrible. The technology stopped being effective and people stopped taking it seriously. And as a consequence of that, there was a need to find a replacement.

"How are we going to attain atonement and alignment with God if the technology of the Temple and it's sacrificial process was breaking down?" And we know that before the destruction of the Temple, rabbinic Judaism began finding replacements for the Temple. The learning of Torah became a substitute for all Temple worship. Yom Kippur, the Holiest of Holies, we talk about what happened then. We hope that our talking, mentioning, fasting, prayer, repentance, all that, we hope it works, and we have been told by the rabbis of old, and reassured that yes, it works. My upgrade actually works.

But at the time 2000 years ago, when the Temple began to crumble, many other groups were looking for replacement "technologies" for the crumbling Temple sacrifice atonement system: "If the Temple system breaks down, how are we going to find atonement?"

One result was Christianity. In other words, Jesus sacrificed himself, became the ultimate sacrifice, so that people would find atonement through that ultimate sacrifice. So Christianity came out saying you know what, we also have a method, we have a technology for atonement and we're sure that it works. It's in the name of Jesus who -- God's son, God's being, God's appointed one, I don't know -- sacrificed himself so that we would find atonement if we mention him, eat of his matzah, his flesh, drink of his blood - we will find atonement.


Interesting indeed.

The Jewish scribes in the Talmud mention that about 40 years before the destruction of the Temple by the Romans in 70 CE, the miracles stopped happening.

The red string would not turn white.

The lights wouldn't burn.

The massive Temple doors swung open on their own. (A new kind of miracle.)

The sacrifices were not accepted.

God was absent from His Temple. To imagine what the Levitical priesthood must have thought at the time - "Where did God go? Why have the miracles stopped?"

"Forty years before the destruction of the Temple, the lot did not come up in the right hand [Lev. 16], nor did the crimson stripe become white, nor did the westernmost light burn; and the doors of the heikhal (the Holy Place of the Temple) opened of their own accord, until Rabbi Yochanon ben Zakkai rebuked them. He said to the Temple:

'O heikhal, heikhal, why do you alarm yourself? I know full well that you are destined to be destroyed, for Zechariah ben Iddo has already prophesied concerning you 'Open thy doors, O Lebanon, that the fire may devour the cedars' (Zech. 11:1).'


--Talmud Bavli, Yoma 39b


Even the secular historian Josephus confirms that something strange was going on with the Temple, saying in his Antiquity of the Jews,

At the same festival [of Pesach/Passover], the Eastern gate of the inner court of the Temple, which was of brass, and vastly heavy, and had been with difficulty shut by twenty men, and rested upon a base armored with iron, and had bolts fastened very deep into the firm floor, which was there made of one entire stone, was seen to be opened of it's own accord about the sixth hour of the night.

-Josephus; The Wars of the Jews 6.5.3


40 years before the Temple's destruction, around 30 CE, the miracles stopped happening and God left his Temple. And one new miracle started happening: the massive Temple doors swung open by their own accord, as if to say, "Hey, I'm not here." 30 CE this started happening.

Anything significant about 30 CE?

Yes: Messiah.

Messiah was sacrificed approximately in 30 CE, 40 years before the destruction of the Temple.

A better sacrifice, a more complete atonement was in place. That's what was significant about 30 CE. That's why the Temple miracles ceased.

Why haven't the Jewish people recognized this event? Surely it is no coincidence the Temple miracles ceased at the same time that this Yeshua, called the Messiah of Isra'el, was sacrificed for the sins of not only Isra'el, but the whole world? Surely G-d had a hand in that!

Paul, an early follower of the Messiah who wrote much of the New Testament, being a Jew himself raised in the Torah as a zealous Pharisee, told us 1900 years ago that this temporary rejection of Messiah by the Jewish people was all planned out by God long ago. It's purpose is to allow the fullness of the gentile nations to come into all the things of God. Here's what he had to say:

Has God has rejected his people Isra'el?

Heaven forbid!

For I myself am a son of Isra'el, from the seed of Avraham, of the tribe of Binyamin.

God has not repudiated his people, whom he chose in advance. Or don't you know what the Tanakh says about Eliyahu? He pleads with God against Isra'el,

"Adonai, they have killed your prophets and torn down your altars, and I'm the only one left, and now they want to kill me too!"


But what is God's answer to him?

"I have kept for myself seven thousand men who have not knelt down to Ba'al."


It's the same way in the present age: there is a remnant, chosen by grace. (Now if it is by grace, it is accordingly not based on legalistic works; if it were otherwise, grace would no longer be grace.)

What follows is that Isra'el has not attained the goal for which she is striving. The ones chosen have obtained it, but the rest have been made stone-like, just as the Tanakh says,

"God has given them a spirit of dullness eyes that do not see and ears that do not hear, right down to the present day."


And David says,

"Let their dining table become for them a snare and a trap, a pitfall and a punishment. Let their eyes be darkened, so that they can't see, with their backs bent continually."


In that case, I say, isn't it that they have stumbled with the result that they have permanently fallen away?

Heaven forbid!

Quite the contrary, it is by means of their stumbling that deliverance has come to the Gentiles, in order to provoke them to jealousy.

What's more, if their stumbling is bringing riches to the world - that is, if Isra'el's being placed temporarily in a condition less favored than that of the Gentiles is bringing riches to the latter - how much greater riches will Isra'el in its fullness bring them!


It was no coincidence that Messiah's sacrifice aligned with the ceasing of miracles in the Levitical sacrifice system; there was an ultimate sacrifice in place. The readings of Torah, the prayers, the traditions, the candles -- all well intentioned things instituted by wise rabbis -- can never atone for sin, year by year. If those human things could atone for sin, there would have been no need for the Levitical system. There would have been no need for Messiah.

It is only with Messiah's sacrifice that completes the Torah sacrifices, can atonement be made for us.

Looking forward to Israel's fullness.

Shalom.

Coming To Terms With The God of Israel

The God of Israel - what an interesting statement.

Israel's God.

Who stands up for Israel's God? For that matter, who is Israel's God? Is it Yahweh? Is it Jesus? Is it the Trinity?

A lot of Christians struggle, perhaps at a subconscious level, about the phrase "God of Israel". After all, Israel's God is the God of Judaism, is He not? And the God of Christianity is not the God of Judaism, right?

Christianity is interesting, perhaps unique or at least rare, in this aspect: its holy book contains the entire holy book of another religion. The whole of Judaism's Scriptures is contained within Christianity's holy book.

Contrast this to, say, Islam, where new writings completely replaced and deemed lies writings of the religion that inspired it. That is to say, Islam was inspired from Judaism and Christianity, but its own holy book denies the writings of both Judaism and Christianity.

(Some Muslims will claim this not true, but in all reality, Islam denies Y'shua (Jesus) is the son of God, thus denying Christian writings, and denies that Isaac (father of Israel) received God's blessings, thus denying Judaism, and that the prophets of Israel prophesied falsely.)

Many Christians are unsure of what they are saying when claiming they worship the God of Israel. Do they really worship Israel's God? If so, why are they so different than the religion of Israel?

This predicament raises other questions: if Christians are worshipers of the God of Israel, why aren't we living in Israel? Why aren't we part of Israel? Joined to Israel? Supporters of Israel?

Over the years, these questions have been answered in many different ways:

  1. Christian theologians theorized that the Christian Church itself is the new Israel. Replacement Theology invented, problem solved.

  2. The Christian Church is a new religion that strayed from the Hebrew faith. The "church" just means the "assembly" of folks who love the God of Israel. The religion of Christianity is done away with, problem solved.

  3. The Christian Church and Israel are two valid, distinct entities. God first loved Israel, now he loves the Church. Israel is belittled, problem solved.

  4. The Christian Church and Israel are two valid, distinct entities. God loves both Israel and the Church. Jews need not convert to Christianity, problem solved.

  5. The Christian Church and Israel are two valid, distinct entities. God loves both Israel and the Church, but Jews still need to convert to Christianity. Israel plays second fiddle to the Church, problem solved.

  6. The Christian Church and Israel are two valid, distinct entities. God is using the Church to bless Israel. Jews need not convert to Christianity, problem solved.

  7. God dispensed -- like a candy dispenser -- different revelations to us over time. He first dispensed that Israel was his people, but we put another quarter in him and he dispensed that the Church was his people. Dispensation Theology invented, Israel done away with, problem solved.

  8. Gentiles are grafted into Israel by Messiah, becoming physical Israelites, not Christians. Christianity is done away with, problem solved.

  9. Gentiles are grafted into Israel by Messiah, becoming spiritual Israelites, not Christians. Christianity is done away with, problem solved.

  10. The Christian Church is the "spiritual" Israel and the Jews are "physical" Israel. God rejected Jews and embraced gentiles, problem solved.

  11. The Christian Church is the "spiritual" Israel and the Jews are "physical" Israel. Jews rejected God, gentiles embraced Him, problem solved.

  12. The Christian Church is the bride of Christ upon his return, Jews will receive the judgment coming to them for rejection of Messiah. Israel done away with, problem solved.

  13. The "Church" and "Israel" are just walled gardens that were invented by men and their religions. The two groups are equally God's children and we ought to all get along. There are multiple paths to God. Christianity and Israel are done away with, problem solved.

  14. The God of the Old Testament is an angry, judgment-loving false god of the Hebrews. The God of the New Testament is the grace-filled, mercy-loving real God who did away with all the Jewish stuff. Israel done away with, problem solved.


Those are just some of the possible answers I'm aware of. And some big names and big organizations adhere to these.

For example, US Presidential candidate John McCain's former pastor, John Hagee, adheres to #4.

Messianic Jews, by and large, adhere to #5.

Messianic Israelites (that is, the movement that says some gentiles are descendants of the northern tribes of Israel), by and large, adhere to #8.

For centuries, if not millenia, the gentile Christian Church, especially the Church at Rome, adhered to #1.

Even today, many gentile Christians adhere to #7.

At least one prominent early Christian father adhered to #14, and even went as far as to create a new Christian bible containing only the writings of Paul.

Many Universalist Unitarians, indeed most of the secular culture, would adhere to #13.

Why does this matter? Theology influences our actions. As Rabbi Derek Leman put it so elegantly, Replacement Theology and sibling doctrines of the early gentile Church resulted in evil actions such as the Crusades and the Inquisition, in turn resulting in the death of thousands of Jews.

Or more recently, during the rise of Hitler's power in Germany, some 70% of Protestant pastors, regardless of their stance on the Nazis, supported the removal of the Jew from der Faderland, after all, the Church replaced Israel!

Or on a yet more recent and somewhat positive note, modern Christian Protestant pastor John Hagee did just the opposite: giving his congregation's money and other aide to Orthodox Jewish organizations in Israel.

This is an important question, then; how greatly it affects our actions! Who is Israel, folks? Do believers in Messiah worship the God of Israel? The same one as the ancient prophets? The same one as the modern Judaism? What theology do you subscribe to, Dear Christian reader?

In the next post, we'll look at what Scripture in the Christian text has to say on this issue, on this mystery that has led to so many ugly actions of Christians over the centuries.

Shalom!

Replacement Theology: A House of Cards

Derek Leman is on fire. The man's recent post dissects Christian Replacement Theology, showing it to be the self-defeating, empty, boastful theology it is.



Replacement Theology, also know as Supersessionism, is the theology that states Christians have replaced Israel as God's people.

Paul, in his letter to the Romans in the New Testament, warned against this kind of theology:

If some of the natural branches have been broken off, and you, though a wild olive shoot, have been grafted in among the others and now share in the nourishing sap from the olive root, do not boast over those branches. If you do, consider this: You do not support the root, but the root supports you. You will say then, "Branches were broken off so that I could be grafted in." Granted. But they were broken off because of unbelief, and you stand by faith. Do not be arrogant, but be afraid. For if God did not spare the natural branches, he will not spare you either.


Replacement theology is boastful -- it is saying, "Ha, we Christians are God's people now! You Jews, well, you had your chance, and you blew it."

This is precisely what Paul was warning against when he had said, "Don't be arrogant - he didn't spare natural branches; by all means he won't spare you in-grafted branches!"

Derek has some insight into this:

Like a house of cards built where there is a gentle breeze, this way of reading the Bible is self-defeating.

It is self-defeating because the Bible is constantly contradicting and challenging an anti-Judaic reading.

You read in Genesis 12, “I will bless those who bless you . . . and in you all the families of the earth will be blessed.”

And you repeat over and over the mantra, “The Bible is the inspired word of God.” But when you read this verse you are forced to say, “This verse, inspired by God, is no longer true. There is no way God’s vehicle for blessing is the Jews. It has to be the Christians.”

You read in Isaiah 54, “This is like the days of Noah to me . . . I have sworn that I will not be angry with you and I will not rebuke you.”

And you think, “God’s word is true but this verse does not mean what it says. God is angry with the Jews. He has rejected them.”

You read in Jeremiah 29, “For I know the plans that I have for you, plans for welfare and not evil.”

And you think, “The Bible is verbally inspired but these words need to be reinterpreted. They should be a promise for Christians and not for Jews. After all, they are on posters in the Youth Room of our church.”

And you read Paul in Romans 11, “God has not rejected his people . . . as regards the gospel they are enemies for your sake; but as regards election they are beloved.”

And you think, “Dare I tinker with Paul? I mean, Isaiah is one thing, but Paul? Yes, to keep my anti-Judaic theology alive I must follow the trend and interpret this verse too as being a blessing for Christians. I know it strains all manner of principles of interpretation. I don’t read the newspaper this sloppily, but, man, I have a theology to defend.”


"I have a theology to defend" is a terrible way to go about interpreting Scripture!

I must admit, I had a little chuckle when I read Derek's point of Jeremiah 29. My son's Christian school has that citation -- "I have plans to prosper you, not to harm you." -- plastered all over the halls, reinterpreting it to apply to young Christian students, rather than to whom Jeremiah was prophesying: Israel.

This kind of re-interpretation of Scripture is afflicting Christianity and leads to anti-Judaic doctrines, which are not only bad theology, but they have also led to anti-Jewish sentiment, even to the point of 75% of German Protestant preachers being anti-Jewish during the Nazi Holocaust.

This is how serious it is, folks. Your theology leads to action, actions lead to consequence. Don't brush this off.

Here's a little story you might find interesting. I was recently listening to Protestant preacher, a kind of cowboy-sounding southern Christian, over the "Full Gospel" radio station here in Minnesota. The preacher was teaching on Paul's letter to the Romans in the New Testament. He got to the part where Paul says, paraphrasing, "The uncircumcised are set right with God through Messiah."

Predictably, The pastor used that as an opportunity to slam the Torah, saying how it is of no use to us, the Torah has passed away, abolished, having been "nailed to the cross", since it's prescription of circumcision makes us no closer to God.

But the next verse from Paul was, "What do we say then? Do we abolish the Law through our faith? May it never be! On the contrary, we establish the Law." The pastor squirmed, "Well... he's not talking about the Law here. Not that Law. He's talking about this new grace law."

Oh boy.

This anti-Judaic bias and theology shined true for him and his congregation; he had to tinker with Paul to make it work.

It's this kind of Scriptural acrobatics that must be performed when seeing "Israel" and reading "Christianity" or "Church". Thank goodness we're seeing this Christian doctrine go the way of the dodo more and more in our day. Good riddance. The world's Jewry will be better off, if not our theology.

Derek said it best, folks:

It is time to deconstruct the Christian, anti-Judaic house of cards. You will feel so free when you do. And the Bible will become an open book to you instead of a mere support system for a handful of Pauline texts quoted out of context. Try it and see.

Breaking News: Israeli Supreme Court Allows Messianic Jews Right of Return

Blogger friend and Messianic Jewish rabbi Derek Leman posts some great news coming from Israel: the Israeli Supreme Court has reversed its 1989 ruling that Messianic Jews are not Jews and therefore cannot emigrate to Israel.

This means Jews that believe Yeshua is the Messiah of Israel are allowed to move to Israel.

The court further ordered the Israeli Minister of Interior, which had been persecuting Messianics by revoking their citizenship, to halt harassments against Messianic Jews.

Baruch Haba BaShem Adonai Yeshua HaMoshiach!



----------------
Now playing: Marty Goetz - For Zion's Sake
via FoxyTunes

Palestinian TV (video)

Often times when I tell people I support Israel, they respond in sympathy to Palestinians. I do my best to explain to these misled souls that the current Palestinian leadership, Hamas and Fatah groups, do not want peace and don't deserve our sympathy. No friends, groups whose charters call for the destruction of Israel and the Jewish people do not deserve sympathy. One would have thought this lesson to be well ingrained into our minds after the Second World War.

Few understand this crux: the Palestinian leadership doesn't want peace. Really, they don't. No, I'm quite serious, they're not interested, not at all. Let that sink into your mind for a moment: "not interested in peace with Israel".

The best orators of the west can't convince them otherwise, so let's stop foolishly pretending we can be peace barters in this ancient, spiritual conflict.

Here's what the Arab leadership and most of the Middle East does want: Israel destroyed and replaced with an Islamic theocracy called Palestine. Harsh reality, folks.

The Palestinian indoctrination of hatred against Israel and Jews is so deep, so vitriolic, it's almost indescribable, incomprehensible to western minds. The best we can liken it to are Hitler's old Germanic speeches we see on historical documentaries.

Earlier this month such hateful rhetoric was broadcast on public TV through the Palestinian territories:







Poor kids.

Just to reiterate, the folks putting on this fine production are the democratically-elected leaders of the Palestinian autonomous state, the ones we're asking to place nice with Israel. Might as well ask Hitler to visit a synagogue while we're at it.

Hey, here's an idea. Let's take some land from Israel (after all, the nation is so big to begin with!) and give it to these fine peace loving folks! Yes, right smack dab in the middle of Israel! No worries, surely everyone will get along just fine!

Hat tip to LGF.

----------------
Now playing: Marty Goetz - Sun and Shield
via FoxyTunes

The Story of the Spoiled Child

There was once a small child who threw tantrums and wreaked all havoc until you gave him a cookie. Now the child had done this many times before, and some folks would, every now and then, give him a cookie, after which he'd be quiet for a little while. Predictably, sooner or later, the boy would get hungry again and would demand another sweet morsel, and thus would throw another fit of rage. "Should we give him another chocolate delight?" Such was the plight of the adults.

Now the child has grown older, but the he still throws tantrums -- in pizza parlors, restaurants, hotels, weddings, grocery stores -- wreaking all kinds of havoc in order to receive attention. The adults, not having learned their lesson, all turn their attention towards the boy and his tantrum, just as the child hoped. The adults wonder what they can do to keep this naughty boy quiet. They inquire of the boy, who tells them,

"I want what my brother has! Now! I won't stop until he gives me what he has!"

The boy throws another tantrum.

The adults, grieved by this unruly one, come to his civilized brother and ask of him,

"Can't you give him some of your possessions? He's your brother after all; just give him a little bit, then he'll stop."

The civilized brother protests,

"But I don't have much to begin with -- my only possession is my estate: my house and my land! It's my historical house; my father has passed this house down to me, and his father before him, going back for 4000 years! And you're asking me to give it away to this misbehaving child? Doesn't my unruly brother already own 23 estates; why doesn't he just use the ones he already has? As for me, I have only this single house to call my own, nothing more!"

The adults persist,

"This will be the last time, the boy has promised to stop his temper fits if you'd just give him what he wants."

The civilized brother feels the pressure from all the adults. He consults his friends, who tell him, "Wise men will not appease evil. What God has given you is yours forever."

At the prospect of noncooperation from the civilized brother, the adults conspire together in their big, luxury estates, far and safe from the tantrums of the boy. They bring the civilized brother into their intervention and demand of him,

"Give the child what he wants, or we shall never speak with you again, nor ever help you in your time of need."

The civilized brother, saddened by this bullying and betrayal, has no choice but to agree. He sends out a respected servant of the house to deliver the news: he will give the boy what he wants.

Eerily, as if by some divine intervention, not 2 years go by before that messenger is killed. The adults, the boy, and the civilized brother all mourn the respected servant's death.

Life went on for the brothers, but the unruly boy, now owning part of his civilized brother's estate, grew full of himself, invigorated with confidence. Despite the civilized brother's hope of a peaceful co-habitat with the boy, tantrums raged once again, much to the chagrin of the peace-bartering adults.

The adults conspire again, wondering what can be done of the problematic boy and his tantrums. As if they had learned nothing from the previous episode, they ask of the child why he is throwing the tantrums again,

"It's mine! My brother is LYING, it's not his estate, this is all mine! I used to live here while brother was in jail, and now I want it back!!!", the boy shouts at the adults.

Taken aback, they solemnly ask if the civilized brother could spare just a little more of his possession. The civilized brother, in shock at the proposition, responds,

"More? In our previous meeting, you assured me this would be the last time I would have to surrender another inch of my estate!"

The adults were crafty and cunning in the art of pressure; history repeated and the civilized brother was, once again, forced to give the boy another portion of his estate. This time, 8000 of the civilized brother's servants were forced to become homeless, as their allotment on the brother's estate was now in the hands of the unruly boy.

Shortly after, almost in the same fashion as the first, a kind of punishment from above was declared: the civilized brother's respected servant, the one who delivered the estate into the hands of the boy, suddenly became deathly ill. Rumor has it the poor servant remains in a coma to this very day.

This cycle repeated a number of times: tantrum, adult intervention, more estate for the boy, less estate for the civilized brother. Each time, something terrible occurred afterwards; the last time this cycle repeated, I am told, a massive storm like one not seen in centuries destroyed much of the adults' luxury estates, killing many of the adults' servants.

But the story is not over, friends, as the suffering of the civilized brother continues even to this day. A wise man tells me the cycle is about to repeat again, but this time on a much grander scale: Not only is the civilized brother being asked to give up more of his estate, but this time, the unruly boy demands a portion of the civilized brother's house itself. The adults are meeting this week, in fact, and are making their demands on the civilized brother this very moment as I convey to you this story. Once again, rumors circulate of the poor messenger that must surrender the land, an apparent doom hanging over his head: does he have cancer? And what of these corruption charges against him? Poor fellow. One can only imagine the wrath induced by the actual division of the civilized brother's very home.

To no surprise, the civilized brother's servants and dear friends are out in the street as we speak, urging the civilized brother to resist the pressure of the adults, lest they themselves be left with no estate, and no house to live in:


Pro-Israel woman holds sign of victims of Palestinian Authority terrorism
Ezra HaLevi

Demonstrator, Annapolis.
Ezra HaLevi

Pro-Israel protestors recite prayers to defend Jerusalem from Israeli government
Ezra HaLevi


Demonstrators at Annapolis.
Ezra HaLevi

Americans For a Safe Israel chapters from around the US came to Annapolis to show support for Israel's territorial integrity
Ezra HaLevi

At the Annapolis rally, in support of One Undivided Jewish Homeland
Ezra HaLevi

Pro-Israel rally to defend Jerusalem from Israeli government concessions
Ezra HaLevi




Religious Jews participated in demonstration calling to maintain Jewish sovereignty over all of Israel
Ezra HaLevi

The elderly joined in the pro-Israel protests
Ezra HaLevi

Young protestor wears shirt with slogan "We will not forget; we will not forgive" in reference to the government's expulsion of 8000 Jews from their homes in Gaza in the summer of 2005
Ezra HaLevi




Meanwhile, the adults toast their wine glasses in delusion, pretending this time the brother's concessions will bring peace.

In those days, yes, at that very time when I put life back together again for Judah and Jerusalem,
I'll assemble all the godless nations.
I'll lead them down into Judgment Valley
And put them all on trial, and judge them one and all
because of their treatment of my own people Israel.
They scattered my people all over the pagan world
and grabbed the land of Israel for themselves.
They threw dice for my people
and used them for barter.

Let the pagan nations set out
for Judgment Valley.
There I'll take my place at the bench
and judge all the surrounding nations.

God's Judgment Day has arrived
in Decision Valley.

The Lord will roar from Zion
and thunder from Jerusalem;
the earth and the sky will tremble.
But the Lord will be a refuge for his people,
a stronghold for the people of Israel.

Then you will know that I, the Lord your God,
dwell in Zion, my holy hill.
Jerusalem will be holy;
never again will foreigners invade her.

-Joel, prophesying of the future Israel


----------------
Now playing: Lamb - Pray For Jerusalem
via FoxyTunes

Custom comments